Download our free Leader and Study Guides from our Resource page.
This is Part 2 of a 5 Part series on the evaluation of Reformed Theology, also referred to as Calvinism. We hope you will join us for this complete series.
The tension between God’s sovereignty and human free will has created theological debates that span centuries. In part 1 of our exploration of Reformed theology, we’ve uncovered both valuable insights and problematic conclusions that deserve careful examination. While Reformed theologians have made significant contributions to our understanding of God’s character and work, certain aspects of this theological system create unnecessary contradictions with Scripture.
In part 2 we begin with a fundamental issue that lies in the Reformed interpretation of total depravity. Classical Calvinism teaches that humanity is so utterly dead in sin that people cannot respond to God in any way without first being regenerated by Him. But this position creates a logical inconsistency. If God wisely chooses whom to save based on His infinite wisdom, yet humans are completely depraved with nothing good in them, then what criteria could God’s wisdom possibly operate upon? Total depravity, as defined by Reformed theology, leaves nothing for God’s wisdom to evaluate or choose. The biblical examples of Cornelius in Acts chapter 10 and Lydia in Acts chapter 16 demonstrate that unregenerated people can indeed seek God and respond to Him before their salvation moment.
Perhaps the most problematic aspect of Reformed theology is its insistence on regeneration preceding faith. RC Sproul himself admitted this concept is central to Reformed Theology, yet Scripture consistently presents the opposite order. Throughout the Bible, we are commanded to believe in order to be saved, not to be saved in order to believe. This reversal creates a theological framework that contradicts the clear gospel invitation where Jesus says, “If you’re thirsty, come to me and I’ll give you a drink.”
Reformed theologians often present a false dilemma: either God causes salvation entirely (monergism) or humans work alongside God (synergism). This dichotomy collapses when we recognize that Scripture consistently contrasts faith and works, showing that faith is not a work. Romans 4:5 states, “To the one who does not work but believes… his faith is credited as righteousness.” Galatians repeatedly contrasts works with faith. By classifying faith as a work, Reformed theology creates an unnecessary contradiction with these clear biblical distinctions.
Another troubling outcome of strict Reformed teaching is the uncertainty it can create about salvation. When theologians like William G.T. Shedd teach that a person convicted of sin who asks for salvation cannot be assured they’re among the elect, they contradict 1 John 5:13, which states, “I have written these things so that you may know that you have eternal life.” This uncertainty has real consequences, as evidenced by people wrestling with whether they’re part of the elect rather than focusing on the assurance Scripture intends to provide.
A more balanced approach recognizes God’s sovereign election while maintaining human responsibility. Lewis Sperry Chafer suggested God has “limitless persuasion” that “induces a favorable reaction,” yet “it still remains persuasion.” When someone decides for Christ, “he exercises his own will, apart from even a shadow of constraint.” This perspective honors both God’s sovereignty and human responsibility without creating unnecessary theological tensions.
God may indeed draw certain individuals more strongly than others for a purpose—Paul’s dramatic conversion experience stands as an example—but this doesn’t mean He only draws those He has predetermined to save. Jesus himself said, “If I am lifted up, I will draw all people to myself.” The gospel invitation remains genuinely open to all who would respond.
As we continue exploring these theological waters, we must remain humble about the mysteries of God’s infinite nature while being faithful to what Scripture clearly teaches. The discussion isn’t merely academic—it affects how we understand God’s character, how we share the gospel, and how believers find assurance in their salvation. Rather than forcing Scripture into a predetermined theological framework, we should let the text speak for itself, even when it challenges our systematic preferences.
Stay with us and continue on to part 3 of our series on Reformed Theology.

