Download our free Leader and Study Guides from our Resource page.
The Question Everyone Must Answer
Matthew 16 brings us to one of the major turning points in the Gospel. Jesus has demonstrated His authority through repeated miracles, taught about the kingdom, confronted religious traditions, and increasingly faced rejection from Israel’s leadership. Now the discussion begins moving toward His death and resurrection.
The chapter opens with religious leaders asking Jesus for another sign. It eventually ends this section with Jesus asking His disciples a much more important question: Who do you say that I am?
Why Did They Ask for Another Sign?
The Pharisees and Sadducees approach Jesus asking for a sign from heaven. At first that request might sound reasonable. If Jesus claims to be the Messiah, why not ask Him to prove it?
The problem is that He already has.
They have seen healings, exorcisms, miraculous feedings, and other signs demonstrating His authority. Their request is not simply an honest search for evidence. They are testing Him and looking for something they can use against Him.
The issue is no longer a lack of evidence. It is what they are willing to do with the evidence they already have.
Seeing Evidence Does Not Guarantee Belief
It is possible to see evidence and still refuse the conclusion.
The religious leaders were experts in Israel’s Scriptures. They knew the prophetic expectations. They had also witnessed what Jesus was doing. Yet they remained unwilling to recognize Him.
Jesus points out the irony. They can read the sky well enough to predict the weather, but they cannot recognize the significance of what is happening directly in front of them.
Sometimes the problem is not that God has failed to provide enough evidence. The problem is that accepting the evidence would require us to change what we already want to believe.
The Sign of Jonah
Jesus refuses to perform another sign simply to satisfy their demand. Instead, He points them to the sign of Jonah.
Jonah was in the great fish for three days and three nights before emerging and continuing his mission. Jesus uses that event as a picture of His own coming death and resurrection.
The religious leaders want a sign. Jesus tells them that the greatest sign is still coming.
The resurrection will stand at the center of the Christian message because it confirms Jesus’ identity and victory over death.
Beware the Leaven
After leaving the religious leaders, Jesus warns His disciples to beware of the leaven of the Pharisees and Sadducees.
The disciples initially misunderstand Him and think He is talking about bread. Jesus reminds them that they have already seen Him feed thousands of people with only a few loaves. Their lack of bread is not the issue.
He is talking about teaching.
Just as a small amount of leaven spreads through an entire batch of dough, false teaching can spread through a religious community.
False Teaching Can Come From Respected Leaders
The warning is especially significant because the Pharisees and Sadducees were not obscure voices on the margins of society. They were among the recognized religious leaders and interpreters of Scripture.
Jesus still tells His disciples to beware of them.
That means position, education, popularity, denominational authority, or religious credentials do not make someone automatically correct.
Christians remain responsible for comparing what they are taught with Scripture.
We should respect teachers, pastors, and leaders, but no human teacher replaces the authority of God’s Word.
The Leaven of Legalism
The Pharisees represent one kind of danger.
They took Scripture seriously, but over time they added more and more rules around it. What may have begun as a desire to protect obedience eventually became a system that burdened people with requirements God had not actually commanded.
Legalism does more than encourage obedience. It adds human requirements and then treats them as though they carry divine authority.
The danger is subtle because it can look deeply religious.
A rule may sound wise or cautious. But when human rules become tests of spirituality that Scripture itself never established, they can become the same kind of burden Jesus condemned.
The Opposite Error
The Sadducees represented a different problem. Rather than continually adding religious rules, they rejected important biblical truths, including the resurrection and other supernatural realities.
Jesus warns about both.
One error adds to what God has said. The other removes from it.
One burdens people with rules God did not give. The other dismisses truths God has revealed.
Faithfulness requires avoiding both extremes and allowing Scripture itself to establish what we believe.
Who Do People Say Jesus Is?
Jesus then takes His disciples to the region of Caesarea Philippi and asks what people are saying about the Son of Man.
The responses vary.
Some say John the Baptist. Others say Elijah, Jeremiah, or another prophet.
Those answers are respectful. No one listed is insignificant.
But every answer is still wrong.
Calling Jesus a great prophet, moral teacher, religious leader, or inspiring figure does not adequately answer the question of His identity.
Jesus does not ask merely whether people admire Him.
He asks who He is.
Who Do You Say That I Am?
Then Jesus makes the question personal.
“But who do you say that I am?”
Peter answers, “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God.”
That confession is a major turning point in Matthew. Jesus has spent much of the Gospel demonstrating His identity through His words and works. Now the disciples clearly confess who He is.
He is not merely one prophet among many.
He is the Christ—the promised Messiah.
He is the Son of the living God.
Public Opinion Cannot Answer the Question for Us
Jesus first asks what the crowd thinks, but He does not stop there.
It is not enough to know what scholars think about Jesus. It is not enough to know what parents, pastors, friends, churches, or cultures say about Him.
Eventually the question becomes personal.
Who do you say that He is?
Every person must answer that question.
We cannot ultimately place the responsibility on someone else and say that we simply followed what another person believed.
God Reveals Spiritual Truth
Jesus tells Peter that flesh and blood did not reveal this truth to him. His Father in heaven did.
That statement reminds us that spiritual truth is not simply the result of human intelligence. Scripture repeatedly presents God as actively revealing truth and drawing people toward Himself.
The word reveal carries the idea of uncovering something that was hidden.
Peter has seen Jesus’ miracles, heard His teaching, and lived alongside Him. Yet Jesus makes clear that understanding His true identity ultimately involves the work of God.
Faith and Understanding
Earlier in the chapter, Jesus connects the disciples’ lack of understanding with “little faith.”
That is worth considering.
Faith does not mean that we will understand every circumstance. There will be many things God allows that we do not immediately understand.
But faith trusts the character of God even when our understanding is incomplete.
The disciples have seen Jesus feed thousands twice, yet they still worry about bread. We often do something similar. God has repeatedly demonstrated His faithfulness, yet the next difficulty can make us forget what we already know about Him.
The Question Still Stands
People continue to give many different answers about Jesus.
Some view Him as a prophet. Others see Him as an important moral teacher. Some dismiss Him entirely. Others admire portions of His teaching while rejecting His claims about Himself.
But Jesus does not leave the question at the level of general opinion.
Who do you say that I am?
Peter answered, “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God.”
That is the question Matthew has been building toward from the beginning.
And it remains the question every person must answer.
Questions discussed in this session include:
- What was the false teachings of the Pharisees and Sadducees?
- What do modern people say about Jesus’ identity?
- What happens when the religious leaders try to box in Jesus by demanding evidence?
- Who do you say that Jesus is?


